shhhh it's a secrit (secritcrush) wrote,
shhhh it's a secrit
secritcrush

Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus by John C. Wright

"Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus" was published in 2013 - the publication date has been sanitized from his website now, but the internet archive remembers. I did a compare documents on the archived version and the one currently up on Wright's website and they appear to be identical. The last scrape on the Wayback machine is 26 December 2014. It tried again on 18 February 2015 and the post was gone. The book of Feasts and Seaons was published on 24 November 2014 so the disappearance doesn't appear to be related to that. (The new page of Wright's site doesn't appear in the Wayback machine, so I can't tell when that went up.)

The Rabid Puppies slate went up on 2 February 2015, right in the window where the page identifying the story as ineligble disappeared. Draw your own conclusions from that.

There appear to be minor edits to the version that was published in 2014 which is approximately 200 words longer (and without any new scenes.) For example, the 2013 version reads:

That is how old Frank had been when they married, seven years ago, looking perfectly handsome with his crooked nose and long jaw and big ears in his splendid dress uniform. He and she had walked under the drawn swords of his fellow graduates on the wedding day. At eighteen, he was in charge of an APC, an armored vehicle that could level a town, wading rivers and crushing buildings, coating the rubble with napalm and trampling it flat beneath its treads. It was smaller than a tank, but Frank loved his squad and what they could do. He loved working with high explosives precisely because it required care and precision and knowing exactly what to do.

while the 2014 version reads:

Eighteen. That was how old Frank had been when they married seven years ago, looking perfectly handsome with his crooked nose and long jaw and big ears in his splendid dress uniform. They had walked under the drawn swords of his fellow graduates together on their wedding day. Now, at twenty-five, he was in charge of an IFV, an infantry fighting vehicle that could blow a hole in a building, wade rivers and crush fences, blasting through walls with high-explosive incendiary rounds before trampling them flat beneath its treads. The M2 was smaller than a main battle tank, but Frank loved his vehicle and what it could do. He loved working with high explosives too, because it required care and precision and knowing exactly what to do.

Hardly a sufficient sort of edit that would qualify as a new story.

I've tweeted to sasquan about this so we'll see how they respond, but I'm not going to waste my time reading something that shouldn't be eligible.

Update - Sasquan have confirmed they are looking into it.
UPdate 2 - Victory! The story has been tossed from the ballot. Gee, now he only has five nominations - whatever will he do.
Tags: hugo madness, hugos, john c wright, pathetic puppies
Subscribe

  • Binti by Nnedi Okorafor

    Novella it a tough length. Most of the time Novellas feel like they are either bloated short stories which could benefit from an edit or a story…

  • The Builders by Daniel Polansky

    This story left me with a lot of questions. Why is this a story about anthropomorphic animals? Why is this a grim dark Western about…

  • Cat Pictures Please by Naomi Kritzer

    One day Google (the search engine) develops consciousness and decides that it doesn't want to be evil, unlike Google the company. So instead the AI…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 12 comments

  • Binti by Nnedi Okorafor

    Novella it a tough length. Most of the time Novellas feel like they are either bloated short stories which could benefit from an edit or a story…

  • The Builders by Daniel Polansky

    This story left me with a lot of questions. Why is this a story about anthropomorphic animals? Why is this a grim dark Western about…

  • Cat Pictures Please by Naomi Kritzer

    One day Google (the search engine) develops consciousness and decides that it doesn't want to be evil, unlike Google the company. So instead the AI…